It's an old fairytale. The princess of an underwater kingdom spots a prince on a ship, and saves him during a storm at sea. He doesn't know it was her, however, since the humans and mermaids can't co-exist, so she leaves before he wakes up.
She falls in love with him from afair, wishing she could be with him...it's quite sad, like most traditional fairytales are.
[ pause ]
The mermaid princess finds a sea witch willing to help her, to give her legs...for a price.
[His gaze shifts to those words with a frown. Feeling like he ought to speak up, ought to protest. But......it's too late for such things. The choice has been made, set in ink if not stone.
And, it was a choice she made freely. She could have picked any number of things; at least the loss of one's voice could be worked around.
So with a quiet sigh and a hand through his hair, Jaguar doesn't pursue his question.]
Well, the mermaid princess earned her legs, although it was a painful transformation. The sea witch gave her an ultimatum--she must get the prince to marry her, and if so, she would be able to live on land with him forever and obtain an immortal soul, something mermaids lacked, apparently. On the morning of his marriage to anyone else, she would dissolve into sea foam and cease to exist.
Things seemed to be going quite well, except when the queen arranged an engagement for her son with a princess from the neighboring kingdom. He said, "do not worry, the only one I could ever love besides you is the priestess who rescued me that day I almost drowned." Except, as it turned out, that priestess was the princess, who had lived at the temple for temporary training.
And so the prince married the priestess-princess, leaving the mermaid princess in the cold. She was resigned to her death, but was suddenly approached by her many older sisters. They'd given the sea witch their beautiful hair in exchange for a magic dagger--if the mermaid princess killed the prince with it, and let his blood splatter on her feet, she would turn into a mermaid again, and be able to live out the rest of her life with her family in the ocean.
She stood by his bed, but she could not bring herself to kill the one she still loved, even if he did not love her anymore. Just as she was about to die, however, she was lifted up into the heavens by many spectral beings. The Daughters of the Air, they said, were beings frozen in a sort of purgatory. Although they did not possess immortal souls, they showed the kindness and grace required to enter the kingdom of Heaven. So, if they kept this up, and helped mankind for 300 years, they would earn their peace.
The mermaid princess set off into the sky to begin her journey.
[ More bittersweet than sad, maybe, but what a fuckin' raw deal that poor girl got. Mermaids not having souls, pssshhh. ]
Fair enough, but consider this--in some retellings of the story, usually the ones where the mermaid princess's tongue was cut out, the prince wasn't quite so nice.
Walking on her new legs was sheer agony, but he asked her to dance for him despite it. He paraded her around more like a trophy, and when he realized who he was to marry, he left her in the dust without a second thought.
I don't think he deserves happiness in those cases, but.....it's easy, too easy, to say that someone unpleasant ought to be killed, especially if there's an injured party involved.
Was he cruel down to his core, or just a spoiled young man? It's a distinction that should be considered. Because usually, death means the end of all potential for change or redemption — killing him would be simpler than forgiveness, but I can't say whether or not it would be the correct choice.
The mermaid would have to judge that for herself, and she did.
I don't disagree. Would it not be better for him to learn of what his misdeeds caused? To say that his poor companion saved him from drowning, and then sacrificed nearly everything to be with him--only for him to reject her at the last moment, condemning her to death. Even then, she still loved him and wished for his happiness. Would that not be the best lesson for him, to have to live with the consequences of his actions for the rest of his life? Atonement is always a choice, and the mermaid princess was not completely damned.
also he drove a ship into a giant sea witch, that checks off at least some criteria for "keeper" material]
That sounds like the more reasonable path to take. Although.....granted, I don't know how I would have reacted if it was me, without the buffer of the story being fiction.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
formaliteas) wrote2015-09-17 11:06 pm
no subject
no subject
Picking up the quill to write down his offer and their roles, then offering it to her.]
no subject
Become the mermaid. ]
no subject
A mermaid?
no subject
Aha, it was a joke, but I probably shouldn't do that here, right? It sort of slipped out.
[ she crosses it out and start writing her actual answer ]
Have you ever read "The Little Mermaid"?
no subject
[Headtilt, thinking back. He didn't grow up with much in the way of fairytales. The name isn't familiar.]
No, I can't say I have. What's it about?
no subject
She falls in love with him from afair, wishing she could be with him...it's quite sad, like most traditional fairytales are.
[ pause ]
The mermaid princess finds a sea witch willing to help her, to give her legs...for a price.
no subject
Mm, I see. What did the sea witch ask for?
no subject
no subject
[Wait. WAIT.]
—that's what you offered?
no subject
It was in turn for the sea witch using her own blood and brewing her strongest potion. Not for anything practical, I believe--payment is payment.
[ She doesn't answer. But he can see her offer written down, anyway. ]
no subject
And, it was a choice she made freely. She could have picked any number of things; at least the loss of one's voice could be worked around.
So with a quiet sigh and a hand through his hair, Jaguar doesn't pursue his question.]
....what happened next?
no subject
no subject
[A wry half-smile.]
One more can't hurt me.
no subject
[ clearing her throat ]
Well, the mermaid princess earned her legs, although it was a painful transformation. The sea witch gave her an ultimatum--she must get the prince to marry her, and if so, she would be able to live on land with him forever and obtain an immortal soul, something mermaids lacked, apparently. On the morning of his marriage to anyone else, she would dissolve into sea foam and cease to exist.
Things seemed to be going quite well, except when the queen arranged an engagement for her son with a princess from the neighboring kingdom. He said, "do not worry, the only one I could ever love besides you is the priestess who rescued me that day I almost drowned." Except, as it turned out, that priestess was the princess, who had lived at the temple for temporary training.
And so the prince married the priestess-princess, leaving the mermaid princess in the cold. She was resigned to her death, but was suddenly approached by her many older sisters. They'd given the sea witch their beautiful hair in exchange for a magic dagger--if the mermaid princess killed the prince with it, and let his blood splatter on her feet, she would turn into a mermaid again, and be able to live out the rest of her life with her family in the ocean.
She stood by his bed, but she could not bring herself to kill the one she still loved, even if he did not love her anymore. Just as she was about to die, however, she was lifted up into the heavens by many spectral beings. The Daughters of the Air, they said, were beings frozen in a sort of purgatory. Although they did not possess immortal souls, they showed the kindness and grace required to enter the kingdom of Heaven. So, if they kept this up, and helped mankind for 300 years, they would earn their peace.
The mermaid princess set off into the sky to begin her journey.
[ More bittersweet than sad, maybe, but what a fuckin' raw deal that poor girl got. Mermaids not having souls, pssshhh. ]
no subject
.....I think she did the right thing.
no subject
Even eclipsing the possibility of returning to her family?
no subject
Of course family is important, but the prince was an innocent person.
no subject
Walking on her new legs was sheer agony, but he asked her to dance for him despite it. He paraded her around more like a trophy, and when he realized who he was to marry, he left her in the dust without a second thought.
Would that still be the correct choice?
no subject
I don't think he deserves happiness in those cases, but.....it's easy, too easy, to say that someone unpleasant ought to be killed, especially if there's an injured party involved.
Was he cruel down to his core, or just a spoiled young man? It's a distinction that should be considered. Because usually, death means the end of all potential for change or redemption — killing him would be simpler than forgiveness, but I can't say whether or not it would be the correct choice.
The mermaid would have to judge that for herself, and she did.
no subject
I don't disagree. Would it not be better for him to learn of what his misdeeds caused? To say that his poor companion saved him from drowning, and then sacrificed nearly everything to be with him--only for him to reject her at the last moment, condemning her to death. Even then, she still loved him and wished for his happiness. Would that not be the best lesson for him, to have to live with the consequences of his actions for the rest of his life? Atonement is always a choice, and the mermaid princess was not completely damned.
no subject
also he drove a ship into a giant sea witch, that checks off at least some criteria for "keeper" material]
That sounds like the more reasonable path to take. Although.....granted, I don't know how I would have reacted if it was me, without the buffer of the story being fiction.
no subject
[ nor did she promise jag her undying love, but you know ]
no subject
I suppose not.
no subject
[ or should she sing an opera while she still has her vocal chords ]
no subject
Would you like to do something to pass the time?
no subject
no subject
There's always the usual guessing game, I suppose. We each think of an object and try to figure out what it is.